Skip to content

Pros and Cons of Dethatching Your Lawn

Any procedure carried out is bound to have a few advantages and disadvantages. Detaching is a procedure that can harm your grass, which is why many individuals often ponder upon the importance of this procedure.

Before you carry out this procedure, you must know the benefits and the disadvantages of detaching. Before deciding, you should weigh the benefits and disadvantages after conducting adequate research. 

To help you make an informed decision and decide whether detaching is worth the hassle, I have broken down the pros and cons of this procedure in the following article.

What Does Lawn Dethatching Mean?

Dethatching your lawn

When you remove excess thatch from a lawn, you’re dethatching it. Thatch is the pile of dead grass blades, stems, roots, and clippings stacked between the living grass blades and the soil.

Once thatch layer is up to a height of 0.5 inches, they become harmful to your turfgrass’ health. Homeowners and gardeners often use rakes and vertical lawn mowers (verticutter) to maintain a healthy lawn.

Pros and Cons of Dethatching Your Lawn 

Dethatching your lawn lets more air, water, sunlight, and fertilizer into it. However, removing the thatch layer exposes the turf to risks such as weeds and adverse weather conditions.

Pros of Dethatching Your Lawn

Pros and cons of dethatching your lawn

Let’s see the benefits of dethatching your turf.

Allows More Sunlight, Air, and Water to Penetrate the Soil 

Dethatching your lawn allows more air and water to reach the soil and the grassroots. That allows the roots to grow stronger and deeper, to give you healthier grass. Moreover, your lawn will better withstand the hot summer if it receives adequate nutrients because you dethatched it. 

Boosts Immunity against Diseases

Too much thatch will prevent oxygen from circulating the lawn. Such unfavorable anaerobic conditions could lead to fungal diseases like the Dollar Spot in your turfgrass.

You want to dethatch your turf to protect its aesthetic against the bleached-white tan or light tan spots caused by a fungal infection.

Additionally, some pathogenic insects love to make a home in dense thatches, sheltering in its moist and warm environment. Dethatching your lawn helps to keep pathogenic insects such as mites or booklice from infesting your space.

Aids Overseeding 

Lawn dethatching will help you achieve more when overseeding the grasses. That’s because thatch barely holds nutrients, compared to soils, and will keep some seeds from reaching the soil.

Removing the dense layer of dead grass cuttings helps to remove any ‘false’ soil area, creating more room for the seeds to germinate. 

Supports Herbicide Penetration

When applying herbicides to your lawn, the chemical needs to reach the roots so it can spread to other weed parts. But if the turf is overgrown with a thick thatch layer, most herbicides won’t reach the soil.

Here’s where dethatching your lawn before herbicide application becomes essential – to aid more efficient herbicide penetration. 

Aids Fertilizer Penetration

Most turfgrass types need fertilizer to grow faster and stay healthy all year round. However, thatch forms a vegetative cover for the lawn’s soil. You want to dethatch your turf so the nutrients you apply can readily get to the soil and aid your turf’s growth.

Cons of Lawn Dethatching

Here are some disadvantages to dethatching your lawn.

Exposes Your Lawn to Weed Infestation

Remember that thatch keeps the grass from nutrients? It also keeps weeds from getting adequate sunlight, water, and air. So, dethatching your lawn will expose the weed to optimum growth situations and support an infestation. 

Increases Vulnerability to Frost

During the winter months, thatch helps to protect your turfgrass from cold air, helping them stay warmer. That’s why lawns with dense thatch layers tend to survive or avoid frost damage during the cold season.

If you dethatch your lawn before or during the cold, your lawn may become less cold-tolerant and succumb to frost damage. 

Makes Your Lawn Vulnerable to Turf Injury

Sometimes, homeowners and gardeners incorrectly use equipment like power rakes and vertical lawn mowers when dethatching their lawns. However, these confrontational tools can injure your turf if you incorrectly use them, like setting the blades too close to the ground. 

Moreover, garden professionals strongly advise against dethatching during spring because it almost always injures your lawn. During spring, your turf is most likely recovering from winter injury and frost damage.

Spring dethatching will tear turf that’s still dormant and will make them unable to recover from the harsh winter conditions. Moreover, using power equipment to dethatch your lawn can bring up harmful weed seeds, setting up your space for a future weed infestation.

Dethatching may dry out the soil

Before you dethatch your lawn, you must consider numerous factors. One of them includes the aridity and the growing conditions of your region.

Thus, if your yard has been undergoing a dry period, most experts advise against opting for dethatching. 

Dethatching your lawn also means that once you complete the procedure, your yard will be exposed to direct sunlight and heat retention.

This eventually leads to increased evaporation which would eventually dry out your soil. In addition to drying out the soil in your yard, this procedure also eliminates various nutrients from the soil.

Therefore, unless the thatch in your yard has adverse effects, we advise against dethatching your lawn as it would prevent vital nutrients from reaching the soil.

Dethatching is a costly and time-taking process

Dethatching is a process that is very time-oriented and requires hours and hours of raking your yard right under the sun. Additionally, detaching is a process that may strain your wallet, depending on the size and the condition of your lawn. 

How Do I Prevent Thatch from Building up on the Lawn?

After reading through the adverse effects of built-up thatch, you’re likely wondering how to ensure your thatch stays below the 0.5-inch level. Here are a few tips to ensure thatch doesn’t build up in your lawn.

Avoid Waterlogging 

Some turfgrasses, like the Eremochloa ophiuroids (centipede grass) need little water to develop properly. Overwatering them will make them grow more thatch.

The recommended watering rate is to water with one inch once a week. Doing that will help you keep your lawn healthy. 

Keep the Lawn Aerated

Since thatch is composed of organic clippings from a living turfgrass, adequate aeration will decompose it. Deeply aerating your lawn soil can help prevent thatch buildup since it loosens the soil and aids soil microbial activities.

Dethatching your lawn

The more decomposing bacteria you have in the soil, the more the thatch decomposes and accelerated decomposition reduces the chances that thatch will build up to harmful levels. 

Adjust and Monitor the Soil pH

Pros and cons of dethatching your lawn

Another factor that directly affects microbial activity is soil pH. Thatch-decomposing microorganisms thrive best at a pH of 6.5. You want to regularly monitor your lawn’s soil pH and adjust it accordingly to prevent thatch buildup. 

A soil pH of 6 or less is too acidic and will prevent the microbial activity of thatch-decomposing bacteria. Liming acidic soil is an excellent way to raise its pH.

Use a Biological (Liquid) Dethatcher

Besides power dethatching tools like vertical mowers and rakes, liquid dethatchers are great tools for helping light thatch layers from piling up.

These biological dethatchers contain organic substances and microbes that hasten the thatch-decomposition process. The result is a thatch height that remains reasonably low. 


There are several benefits of dethatching your lawn. Lawn dethatching helps to keep your grass aerated and open to nutrients. It also aids fertilizer, nutrients, and herbicide application, helping to keep the grass lush and green

However, it’s always vital to dethatch appropriately and infrequently. You may have good motives to remove old leaves and debris from your lawn, and it could just feel good to go out and dethatch—your lawn. Your turfgrass won’t need dethatching until the thatch has reached up to ½ inch in height.


How Long Will It Take Before a Lawn Recovers after Dethatching?

After dethatching, your lawn will take about 21 to 28 days to develop new turfgrass.

Can You Dethatch Wet Grass?

While you move a rake or power equipment to remove thatch from wet grass, it’s not advisable. Dethatching wet grass will expose your lawn to physical damage, especially when you use dethatching equipment. Wet thatch will clog your power equipment, reduce its effectiveness and complicate your task. 

Should You Reseed after Dethatching the Lawn?

Yes. Reseeding your lawn after dethatching will help replace the grass your dethatching session removed. 

Ian richardson

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.